2.6 KiB
Executable File
2.6 KiB
Executable File
Prompt Review Session Template
Version: 1.0 (2025-03-25)
PURPOSE
This template facilitates a structured review of prompts developed during the initial engineering session to refine and optimize their effectiveness.
PREPARATION CHECKLIST
- Initial prompt draft ready for review
- Test results from initial implementation documented
- Review team assembled with appropriate expertise
- Success criteria clearly defined
- Previous session notes accessible
SESSION STRUCTURE
1. PROMPT PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT
[PROMPT UNDER REVIEW]:
[INITIAL SUCCESS CRITERIA]:
[PERFORMANCE METRICS]:
[AREAS MEETING EXPECTATIONS]:
[AREAS REQUIRING IMPROVEMENT]:
2. STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS
2.1 Context Effectiveness
[SUFFICIENT BACKGROUND PROVIDED?]: Yes/No
[MISSING CONTEXT ELEMENTS]:
[SUPERFLUOUS CONTEXT ELEMENTS]:
[CLARITY OF DOMAIN KNOWLEDGE]:
2.2 Instruction Clarity
[AMBIGUOUS INSTRUCTIONS IDENTIFIED]:
[CONFLICTING GUIDELINES IDENTIFIED]:
[INSTRUCTION HIERARCHY CLEAR?]: Yes/No
[GUARDRAIL EFFECTIVENESS]:
2.3 Format Adherence
[FORMAT REQUIREMENTS MET?]: Yes/No
[STRUCTURAL INCONSISTENCIES]:
[STYLISTIC DEVIATIONS]:
[QUALITY OF OUTPUT STRUCTURE]:
2.4 Example Utility
[EXAMPLES PROPERLY REFERENCED?]: Yes/No
[EXAMPLE DIVERSITY SUFFICIENT?]: Yes/No
[MISSING EXAMPLE SCENARIOS]:
3. CONTENT QUALITY EVALUATION
[FACTUAL ACCURACY]:
[COMPLETENESS OF CONTENT]:
[LOGICAL FLOW]:
[APPROPRIATE TONE]:
[TERMINOLOGY CONSISTENCY]:
4. OPTIMIZATION STRATEGIES
4.1 Targeted Improvements
[SPECIFIC ELEMENT]:
[CURRENT STATE]:
[PROPOSED REVISION]:
[RATIONALE]:
4.2 Experimental Variations
[VARIATION A]:
[VARIATION B]:
[COMPARISON METHODOLOGY]:
[SUCCESS INDICATORS]:
5. REVISED PROMPT
[UPDATED FULL PROMPT TEXT]:
6. VALIDATION TESTING
[TEST SCENARIO 1]:
[OUTCOME]:
[IMPROVEMENT FROM ORIGINAL?]: Yes/No/Partial
[TEST SCENARIO 2]:
[OUTCOME]:
[IMPROVEMENT FROM ORIGINAL?]: Yes/No/Partial
7. IMPLEMENTATION RECOMMENDATIONS
[GO/NO-GO DECISION]:
[RECOMMENDED DEPLOYMENT CONTEXT]:
[MONITORING REQUIREMENTS]:
[EXPECTED MAINTENANCE FREQUENCY]:
8. NEXT STEPS
- Finalize prompt documentation
- Schedule follow-up review if needed
- Plan implementation strategy
- Update continuity document with review outcomes
NOTES
- Use validation checklist to prevent redundant testing
- Document all stakeholder feedback received
- Consider A/B testing for significant changes
- Flag edge cases for special handling
Cross-reference with: Validation Checklist, Initial Prompt Engineering Session, Continuity Document