incident-log: pwvault web-vault EncString crash case (2026-09-09)

Full symptom/root-cause/repair record for the InvalidTypeSymm
web-vault crash so it is never re-derived.
https://projects.knownelement.com/issues/942
This commit is contained in:
2026-09-09 18:59:11 -05:00
parent 5b6baa7ff7
commit f7d54a30ae
2 changed files with 63 additions and 0 deletions
+41
View File
@@ -267,3 +267,44 @@ the workspace STATUS/memory.
first login. first login.
- `scripts/totp.sh <base32-seed>` — current 6-digit TOTP code (pure bash, - `scripts/totp.sh <base32-seed>` — current 6-digit TOTP code (pure bash,
RFC-7636-vector tested). RFC-7636-vector tested).
## Vaultwarden app (pwvault.turnsys.com) — known issue, quirks, and repair (2026-09-09)
The fleet vault is a Cloudron **Vaultwarden** app (`com.github.bitwardenrs`,
container id 48757d8a-… on tsys-cloudron-new; DB = **MySQL** database from
the app container env `CLOUDRON_MYSQL_DATABASE`, on the shared `mysql`
container — NOT sqlite; a stray `db.sqlite3` in /app/data is junk).
**Known web-vault crash (upstream bug, Vaultwarden discussions #7334/#7464):**
the 2026.7.0 web client + strict WASM SDK crash with
`Unhandled error in angular: EncString(InvalidTypeSymm { enc_type: "0", parts: 1 })`
during vault load → empty vault / endless spinner, on every browser, while
native apps (iPad/desktop) and API-key clients work fine. Triggered by an
account key-pair record the client's strict parser rejects
(`accountKeys.publicKeyEncryptionKeyPair.publicKey` stored as a raw base64
public key instead of an EncString). Repair that worked:
`UPDATE users SET public_key = NULL WHERE uuid = '<uid>';` in the MySQL DB
(take a Cloudron app backup first: `POST /api/v1/apps/<id>/backup` with
`{"backupSiteId":"<id from GET /api/v1/backup_sites>"}`, poll
`/api/v1/tasks/<taskId>`); the client regenerates a proper key pair on next
login. NEVER write to the DB without a fresh backup + explicit founder
approval for the pwvault container.
**CLI 2FA quirk:** CLI-style logins (`client_id=cli`) are offered ONLY the
recovery-code provider — an authenticator TOTP seed from the vault will be
rejected at the 2FA prompt even when the authenticator is correctly
enrolled (browser sessions get the authenticator prompt; CLI does not).
Automated flows must use the **API key** (client_credentials grant), which
bypasses 2FA entirely — `creds/cloudron`-style API keys are the automation
path, passwords+TOTP are for humans in browsers.
**Cloudron backup API pattern** (for pre-surgery backups): GET
`/api/v1/backup_sites` → site id; POST `/api/v1/apps/<id>/backup` body
`{"backupSiteId":"<id>"}`; poll `GET /api/v1/tasks/<taskId>` until
`success:true`. Response field is `taskId` (not `id`).
**TOTP seeds**: the account's authenticator seed for coo@turnsys.com is
`BW_TOTP_SECRET` in `/data2/TSGCOO/.config/bw/env` — keep it in sync with
what is actually enrolled server-side; a stale seed there was the source of
a multi-hour misdiagnosis (the "wrong password"/"stale seed" theories).
Clock skew was ruled out (workstation and server within 1s).
@@ -50,3 +50,25 @@ rabbit hole (see #939 correction).
--- ---
**Records:** Redmine #942 — https://projects.knownelement.com/issues/942 · Discourse docs home: https://community.turnsys.com (skill topic pending admin-key provisioning, tracked on #942) **Records:** Redmine #942 — https://projects.knownelement.com/issues/942 · Discourse docs home: https://community.turnsys.com (skill topic pending admin-key provisioning, tracked on #942)
## 2026-09-09 — pwvault web-vault crash: EncString InvalidTypeSymm
- Symptom: web vault (all browsers, incl. fresh private windows) spins
forever after successful password + authenticator 2FA login; zero items.
iPad native app + extension worked throughout; CLI (API key) worked.
- Root cause: the account's `accountKeys.publicKeyEncryptionKeyPair.publicKey`
stored a RAW base64 public key ("MI…", not an EncString). The 2026.7.0
web client's strict SDK parser rejects it → `InvalidTypeSymm { enc_type:
"0", parts: 1 }` → unhandled Angular error aborts vault render.
Upstream: vaultwarden discussions #7334, #7464; issue #7469.
- Repair: `UPDATE users SET public_key = NULL` (MySQL db for the app;
coo@ = user uuid 98954ef9-…), then client login regenerates the pair.
Cloudron app backup taken first via the backup API (backup_sites →
task poll). Verified end-to-end same day.
- Diagnostic technique that found it: Firefox F12 → Console tab captured
the unhandled Angular exception; server logs + API probes showed
everything healthy; the crash was client-render only.
- Related: CLI-style logins (client_id=cli) are offered only the recovery
code 2FA provider — authenticator TOTP codes from a vault seed are
rejected for CLI logins even with the authenticator correctly enrolled.
Automation uses API keys (bypass 2FA), not passwords+TOTP.